Creating Deserts (Excerpts)
“Here is a country where governing means creating deserts”
This cry of despair was voiced by Brazilian anthropologist Eduardo Viveiros de Castro when he learned of the fire at Rio de Janeiro’s National Museum in September 2018—the worst museological disaster in the country’s history. For me, this powerful statement marks a moment of awareness and the starting point of a project currently nearing completion, which accompanies and extends the series Île Brésil and My Body Is Political. The images presented here address Brazil’s predatory relationship with its own natural environment.
From the time I settled in the country, and as I gradually took root, I quickly sensed that the relationship to the surrounding environment—almost systematically conceived as something to be exploited rather than preserved—reflected a singular mindset, specific to Brazil. It took me several years, however, to begin to decipher this specificity, in a country where, as Brazilians themselves say, “light reveals as much as it conceals,” and whose complexity is deeply compelling.
In Brazil, the mechanism of conquest begins, etymologically, with the invasion of the territory by the Portuguese in the early sixteenth century. The forced appropriation of land was immediately extended through the implementation of forced labour, based on the transatlantic slave trade—half of all enslaved people deported worldwide were sent to Brazil. Historically—and this has not changed today—the predation of nature has always been encouraged by Brazil’s vast scale, its isolation, and the fact that it is largely made up of immense, sparsely inhabited territories. Until relatively recently, it was difficult to assign a specific political colour to this culture of environmental exploitation, as it stemmed from a mindset that had permeated all levels of society.
Over the past decade, however, a conservative and far-right bloc—still highly influential despite Jair Bolsonaro’s defeat in the 2022 presidential election—has come to embody and promote a form of predation unprecedented in its intensity, and which, in environmental terms, represents a threat to Brazil’s future and far beyond.
Through a perverse interplay of ideological alliances and converging economic interests, this movement brings together advocates of order and representatives of the powerful agro-industrial sector. In military schools, whose numbers have surged over the past decade, discipline and love of country are taught as core values. Evangelical pastors relay the same message, giving it a spiritual and millenarian foundation. Agribusiness, which dominates the centre-west of the country and now surpasses the traditional southern elites in wealth and power, draws on the immense popularity of sertanejaculture to impose its rural and conservative values.
Their message is simple: God has endowed Brazil with almost limitless natural resources. Exploiting these riches on an industrial scale is presented as a patriotic act, one that concerns Brazilians alone. Formulated in 2018, Eduardo Viveiros de Castro’s bleak diagnosis has never seemed more relevant—or more prophetic.
This was followed by successive economic cycles of exploitation—always tied to raw materials: sugarcane and coffee in the past, intensive agriculture and hydrocarbons today—which have shaped the country’s topography and its social structure.